About a year ago I bought some shares in Annaly Capital Management, Inc. (NLY). NLY is a REIT that is highly leveraged and pays out a substantial dividend yield.
I bought 26 shares at a price of $18.35 per share. The total investment was $477.10. In the past year I've received dividend payments of $65.26 total.
Today NLY is now trading at just $16.18. Combining the dividend payments of $65.26 and the current capital value of $420.68 the value is now $485.94.
In total I'm up roughly 1.8% for the year on the investment.
The S&P 500 went from 1258 to 1234 in the same period so its down marginally by about 2%.
The Vanguard REIT ETF (VNQ) is virtually flat as well going from 55.17 to 55.13. But the ETF has paid out about $2 in that time. So in total VNQ is up around 3.6%
Considering that the NLY is up only 1.8% and the Vanguard REIT ETF is up about 3.6% I don't consider my NLY investment a very good one. Buying the diversified ETF would have been a lot safer and it has performed better as well.
I decided to sell my shares of NLY. When I bought the idea I had in my head was that I'd make >10% dividend and expected that the market value of the shares would likely stay flat. I knew the investment was a little risky given how NLY operates. But I figured (hoped) with a 10%+ dividend that it would be hard to go wrong. I didn't figure or really expect the market value of the shares to drop like they did. I don't consider this investment a success but on the other hand I didn't lose money.
--