Updated list of items under $2 eligible for Amazon Subscribe & Save :
JELL-O Dessert Mold Kit, Strawberry, Texas A&M University, 12 Ounce = $1.06
BC Analgesic Powder, 6 Count (aspirin) = $1.26
Pac-Kit 1-009 Fabric Adhesive Light Woven Flexible Knuckle Bandage, 3" Length x 1-1/2" Width (Box of 8) = $1.33
Dial Liquid Antibacterial Soap, Himalayan Pink Salt & Water Lily, 7.5 Ounce = $1.42
Munik Soto Ayam Chicken Soto Soup Seasoning, 70-Gram = $1.47
Velveeta Kraft Cheesy Skillets Dinner Kit Box, Creamy Beef Stroganoff, 11.6 Ounce = $1.68
Speed Stick Deodorant, Regular, 1.8 Ounce = $1.69
Lawry's Seasoned Salt, 8 Ounce =$1.70
Crystal Body Deodorant Travel Stick, Unscented, 1.5 Ounce = $1.76
Tea Xotics Tea Blend, Boston 1773- Black, 1.75 Ounce= $1.77
Keebler Fudge Shoppe Grasshopper Cookies, Mint, 10 Ounce = $1.88 (cookies!!)
Permatex 25575 Fast Orange Pumice Bar Hand Soap, 5.75 oz. Bar =$1.95
I try to list a variety of items so you'll have a better chance of seeing something on this list that you'd actually get use out of so its not just bought and wasted.
Warning : If you use items off this list then make sure to watch them and cancel your subscription if you no longer want them or if the prices go up. The cheap items I find seem to change pretty quickly so they may have large price hikes or be removed from the subscribe and save program.
Note the list will get out of date within months or days. I'll probably post a newer list before all of the above items are gone or have price increases. But if you can't find something good here you can always go to Amazon and search for Subscribe & Save and sort based on prices and poke around to find something cheap to use as a filler.
I've discussed before how you can get a better discount on Amazon Subscribe and Save purchases if you order 5 items at once. However if you don't buy a lot of stuff then it can be hard to come up with a 5 item order. However if your products are worth enough then it can be worth it to add some filler items to get up to 5 items to get the 15% discount.
Say for example, you want to buy a couple cases of Pampers Swaddlers Diapers that run $45.97 each with a normal purchase. With Subscribe and save you'd get a 5% discount.to get the price down to $43.67. But if you have 5 items in your S&S order then it is only $36.78 or a $6.89 savings. And if you're buying two of those then thats double or $13.78. Adding the 4 cheapest items listed here to the S&S order would only cost you $4.99 total with the 5 item discount so its worth buying those items to get you a net savings of $8.79.
Note if you don't want the filler items and only use them to get a 5 item discount then you can of course always give away the food items to someone you know or donate them to the local food bank.
--This article may contain referral links which pay this site a commission for purchases made at the sites.