October 22, 2013

Only About 2% of Retirement Assets Are Held in Roth IRAs

If you read all the personal finance sites and blogs like I do you'd get the impression that everyone and anyone has a Roth IRA and that they're a really big deal.   Well not so much in reality.  

A little under 2% of all retirement funds are held in Roth IRAs.

I figured that from data in the EBRI issue brief titled IRA Balances and Contributions: An Overview of the EBRI IRA Database.   The data in the report is for 2008 so its a little dated, but I'm assuming the mix of moneys in retirement accounts hasn't changed drastically.

First I jump forward to Box Figure A in the report that shows that about $13.3 trillion was held in retirement accounts and 26.8% of that or $3.6T is in IRAs or Keoghs. 

Next look at Figure 1 in the report that breaks down the % of different kinds of IRA accounts people have.

Here is are those #'s :

Now you might be tempted to think that if IRAs are 26.8% of retirement and 23.4% of IRAs are Roths that would mean that 26.8% x 23.4% of retirement funds are in Roths.   But thats not the case because the average balance in a Roth is actually much lower than the average balance in other IRAs.

The average balance by IRA account type out of Figure 3 in the report are :

You can see the Roths hold the smallest balances.

Roths account for just under 6% of the total money in IRAs.    And as IRAs are 26.8% of all retirement funds then that means that Roths hold about 1.6% of all retirement money.


1 comment:

  1. Interesting find here, as like you said almost every financial site or personal finance blog is always pushing to use a Roth IRA. Who would have thought the % was so low? I currently contribute to my normal 401k up to employer match and then max out my Roth IRA so I have a balance of tax deferred and tax free accounts.


I'm starting to get too many spam messages in the comments so I'm turning on moderation. Please be patient and wait for your comment to be approved. Note it may take up to a few days for approval, thanks. I've also had to remove anonymous posting of comments to cut down on spam and pure stupidity.

Blog Widget by LinkWithin